Back in the 1980s, I had a mental breakdown that was brought on by stress and four untreated duodenal ulcers. My treatment included a programme of sessions with a clinical psychiatrist. One of the strategies they advised me to use whenever I have a problem that I could not resolve was to write about it. They were right, and the process of writing helps me to clarify my thoughts ... and this is the reason why I have written this blog post.
Regular blog readers might have noticed that I've not mentioned my Belle Époque project much lately. The reason for this is that I seem to have stalled ... and cannot find a way to restart it.
I am still very enthusiastic about it, and to date I have:
- Written a set of specific Portable Belle Époque Wargame rules.
- Created twelve suitable imagi-nations, including:
- Backstories for each.
- National flags.
- National armies (including marines and a naval brigade for one of the nations).
- A separate, dedicated blog.
- I have also acquired:
- A couple of 1:100th-scale steam traction engines (they were originally part of the range of diecast 'Thomas the Tank Engine' toys).
- Several 100th-scale Bleriot XI monoplanes.
- A range of 87th-scale 009 and H09 locomotives and rolling stock ... and a lot of KATO N-gauge track.
So, what's missing?
The answer is MAPS!
Regular blog readers will already know that I have been trying to solve this over recent months ... but – to date – I just cannot seem to find a solution that feels right. I do have a basic layout diagram for my Belle Epoque imagi-world.
This presently includes an additional as-yet-unnamed imagi-nation which may or may not be added in due course.
I did ask ChatGPT to render this diagram into map form, and it came up with this:
It is – without doubt – a great starting point for me, but every time I have tried to move forward, my attempts have just not worked for me.
However, looking back at the PORTABLE WARGAME Facebook page, I found a very interesting posting by Mark Cordone from last July. In it, he described a way in which he used the cards from RISK to create a map. His method was described as follows:
The area was going to be continent sized so I drew four cards and arranged them in a way I found interesting to create an outline.
Then I added some mountains, more or less in line with the geography of the regions on the cards, then added some rivers.
Then I placed my countries, then some lakes and islands before locating the cities. The key to a decent looking map is not to get carried away adding too many details. More detailed maps can be easily produced by photocopying your map and drawing on a grid and using it to enlarge a particular area.
Once I was done with that I coloured it in using coloured pencils. Brown for semi arid and dessert, yellow -green for plains, green for mixed county and dark green for forest or jungle.
This little map is hardly a masterpiece, but it looks pretty good and will do nicely as a geographical reference for my games. It was a fun little project and only took about an hour and a half to complete.
Mark Cordone's original choice of four RISK cards.
Mark Cordone's final map.
Perhaps I have found a way forward? Who knows ... but I think that I will have fun finding out if this method works for me!
Please note that the last two images featured above are © Mark Cordone.




Bob The AI version of your rough draft is rather good - with a bit more detail it would be a nice Campaign Map.
ReplyDeleteMark C is full of great ideas!
Maudlin Jack Tar,
DeleteThe ChatGPT map certainly turned out better than I expected, and will make a good starting point for me.
Mark Cordone is a positive fountain of ideas and inspiration … and has yet again contributed to the next compendium.
All the best,
Bob
I actually prefer yours Bob, but both ideas work. I was tempted to use part of the Risk map for Imaginations (I went through a stage of buying Risk figures for it, then I found buying the old games off eBay was cheaper, so ended up with lots of spare stuff and hundreds of figures!).
ReplyDeleteJeffers,
DeleteThanks very much for your kind comment. Thanks to the feedback I’ve had, I think that I have found a way forward … so watch this space!
RISK - in its various formats - is a great source for figures. I have copies of the original game, the LOTR edition, thr Europe, and the English Heritage edition. The latter two are particularly useful as sources for Medieval figures. If you can find copies on eBay or in charity/thrift shops, but them!
All the best,
Bob
The chatgpt map is a good place to start. Maybe draw 5-6 Risk cards and arrange them to follow the outline for the coastlines and to suggest the placement of hills, rivers and mountains?
ReplyDeleteMark Cordone,
DeleteThanks very much for the ideas you’ve shared. I think that I’ve now got a starting point for my campaign maps.
All the best,
Bob
For myself I ask a number of questions.
ReplyDeleteWhat terrain do I want to fight in?
What natural borders shape the nations?
How big is the country?
Once built how many different ways can it be used?
Function Vs beauty? I map I can use is far better than one that is pretty. I currently am working on a map of islands. The first version is the outlines with simple point-to-point area boxes, similar to GDW's House Decided or Soldier King maps. I am now working to make it pretty so that when I post pictures it has a better visual appeal.
I hope this helps your focus, especially deciding what is important for your experience.
WEK 3,
DeleteThose are excellent questions … and they will help me design my maps. Thank you for posing them.
I think that they are going to start as functional maps - probably with point-to-point and/or area movement - that can be improved over time,
All the best,
Bob
I like Mark Cordone's map and method.
ReplyDeleteI've always loved maps, playing around with real maps and fictional ones, drawing my own, looking at ones other people have made, seeing methods for coming up with maps, techniques for creating maps and for drawing them or painting them or other ways of producing them, etc. It's why I made a career of geography.
In any event, good luck with your Belle Epoque project! Sounds like you might have found a road map for a way forward. :D
Fitz-Badger,
DeleteMark Cordone seems to have a talent for producing excellent wargame maps.
I also love maps, and our house has several of the area where we live on the walls. They show how the area has developed over the past two hundred years, from a very agricultural area into a suburban one that still has large open spacesnd woodlands.
All the best,
Bob
Very interesting! I like what Chat-GPT did with the Eastern nations, the slight offsetting creating some new connections and possibilities; maybe that would work in the NW of the map too.
ReplyDeleteJWH,
DeleteCheers! I must admit that ChatGPT's map was better than I had expected, and although I won't be copying it exactly, I will certainly be using it as a guide.
All the best,
Bob
Hi Bob
ReplyDeleteI also spent many years trying to develop a campaign map system which suited what I wanted to achieve. Each of us have very different objectives and requirements, and I am not suggesting that I have found an answer for anyone other than myself. But I though it might help if I just state the building blocks which led to my current system.
First start with what you have, and then consider what you want to achieve. If this is a large physical area don't attempt to reach the end product in one go.
In my case my wargames table was the starting point. That became the first building block, and it was a town and surrounding area on the map. 9 of them became a district and so on, "x" districts a region. Each country had a number of regions depending on its size.
Personally I find AI to be very useful, but it stiffles my imagination. It can give advice, but I prefer to do the actual work myself. Asking it to produce the finished product is like buying a map from a shop, rather than making it up yourself. However once the hand made, or computer assisted, map is complete AI is great at improving the look of the whole thing.
Good luck with your map, I have had hours of pleasure (and some frustration) working on mine.
regards
Paul
Paul Leniston (Paul),
DeleteThanks for your excellent advice, which I know is the result of lots of development work done by you over many years.
I particularly like the 'don't attempt to reach the end product in one go' advice ... especially as I am prone to doing the opposite of what you advise! I am going to follow your advice about using the tabletop as my starting point ... and I have recently come to the conclusion that I am going to use a 12 x 12 square grid of 50cm squares as the basis of my future tabletops.
I am even thinking of creating a number of tabletop terrain boards or tiles, very much along the lines you outlined in your recent blog posts.
I agree that AI has its uses, particularly when it comes to tidying up something that is already 99% finished. I found this when I asked ChatGPT to produce a thumbnail for one of my videos based on the one I had already created.
All the best,
Bob
Bob -
ReplyDeleteIt's all there, all right, although, if you decide to use the ChatGPT map, might I suggest placing Britannia OVER Burgundy, having a common border with Schwarzenburg (or maybe a strait between the two if Britannia is an island nation)? Creates a geopolitical situation with more ... tension... one feels.
To get the thing started, you might want to create a kind of 'back history' with tensions and conflict between pairs of nations just to get a 'feel' for the geopolitical dynamics of your world. That was actually one of the motivations for my Kavkhan campaign a few years ago.
The geography can be a real problem. I'm having to rethink my map for the 'Hunt for Sextus Pompey' (damn) - which in the end will look quite a bit like MC's Hoplite game, but with more emphasis on naval action, at least early on. I'm hoping that will work.
I don't really much like my 'Little Great Wars' maps, but have decided to run with them, regardless. The Azuria campaign has a very wide strategic scope for three army corps the side! They have yielded some interesting battles (I have yet to narrate the two battles so far between Izumrud-Zeleniya and Turcowaz).
All my 'Jono's World' battles have so far been 'situational' with only the vaguest reference to the map. I rather think that very soon I'll have to create a proper map, probably only loosely based on Jono's original. The one I did create does have its limitations, I think. But I mention this as maybe a way to dip your toe into your Belle Epoch' world - situational battles or mini-campaigns, perhaps snippets of back-historical conflicts. That has been generally my approach. I don't worry overmuch whether it will create 'continuity glitches' once the main story gets under way...
Please accept my gratuitous remarks as my own 'therapeutic' outlet for rather similar situations in which I find myself.
Cheers,
Ion
Archduke Piccolo (Ion),
DeleteI want to make Britannia an island that is off the coast of Burgundy ... and not too far from the western part of Schwarzenburg!
I have written a backstory for each of the imagi-nations, and have included some indication of potential conflicts. Perhaps I ought to share it on my blog?
I suspect that if I can ever get my Belle Epoque project started, it may well end up being my own version of your Little Great War, where numerous imagi-nations end up fighting each other. But to do that, I need to start work on my maps! Even a set of not very good ones will be better than what I have at present!
I'll get there one day ... I hope!
All the best,
Bob
Bob! Glad you’ve found a solid way forward with the project—looking forward to seeing how it develops.
ReplyDeleteAll the best, Andy
Andrew Bruce (Andy),
DeleteI now have a workable plan that I can follow ... and I hope to do so very soon!
All the best,
Bob
Delighted to hear this Bob.
DeleteTradgardmastare,
DeleteI hope to begin work on my first map later today ... and when it's ready, I'll write a blog post about it.
All the best,
Bob