Once the muddy part of the marsh was done, I began to look at ways in which to replicate the vegetation found in a marsh. In the end I decided to experiment with a method based on one that I had seen for modelling hedges. The main components were:
- Pan scourers.
- Various acrylic paints.
- PVA glue.
- An old (i.e. disposable if necessary) soft paintbrush.
- An assortment of different green and brown scatter material.
- A jar of warm water.
- A bowl of warm water.
Other than the green pan scourers – which were bought as a pack of five from a local supermarket – I had everything that I needed to hand.
Before I outline the method than I used, I need to issue a warning to anyone contemplating copying it: it is very messy and should only be done on a surface that has been properly covered in old newspapers or a waterproof sheet. I also advise that a large roll of kitchen towel be kept close to hand to mop up any overspills and to dry one's hands one.
- First, I took a green pan scourer and randomly dropped dollops of green and brown acrylic paint over its surface. (I used Oxide Chromium Green, Viridian, Sap Green, and Burnt Sienna acrylic paints previously bought from craft shops.)
- I then used the brush to work the paint into the surface of the scourer until the whole surface was covered. Dipping the brush into the jar of water helped this process.
- The scourer was then scrunched up into a ball as tightly as possible. (Warning: If you attempt to duplicate this method, wet and runny paint will ooze out and drip as you do this and will cover your hands ... so be careful!)
- Once I was satisfied that the paint has well and truly been forced into the scourer, I rinsed it out in the bowl of clean water, and squeeze-dried by hand. I then placed it to one side on something absorbent (and disposable, such as a number of layers of kitchen towel) and allowed it to dry.
- Once this has been done, I cleaned up the area I had used very thoroughly to ensure that domestic calm was maintained!!!
Before gluing pieces of my home-made foliage in place on the board, I cut one of the three pan scourers I had prepared into small, randomly-shaped pieces, which I placed at various locations around and in the marsh.
Until this point, I felt that everything was going well ... and then I realised that my experiment was actually not going to work! The result did not just look bad; IT LOOKED AWFUL!
Back to the drawing board!
The third photo looks pretty good to my eyes but maybe more for moorland than a marsh, interested to see how you tackle this problem.
ReplyDeleteDonnie McGibbon,
DeleteNoe that’s a great ideal! They’d make excellent dense moorland! Thanks very much for your suggestion.
All the best,
Bob
Awful? We don't disagree much but this is one of those times. Had you cropped the picture of the results I'd swear it was a screenshot from Google maps or an aerial photo.
ReplyDeleteBut it's your project, so good luck in your next attempt.
Mr. Pavone,
DeleteThe photo made it look better than is was. Anyway, I’ve found a better method which I will share with my regular blog readers in due course.
All the best,
Bob
Looking good. I'm looking forward to seeing the complete layout. This brings back memories of my childhood, my dad had an HO layout in the basement which got taken over for wargames with my Airfix World War two soldiers. It was great fun! 😁
ReplyDeleteMark Cordone,
DeleteI’m hoping to get it finished by the end of January. As to having a model railway layout that’s used for wargaming … well, that’s something I’m giving serious thought to.
All the best,
Bob
At least the experiment was successfully cleaned up with no unexpected stains left behind.
ReplyDeletePeter,
DeleteWe learn from our mistakes, and I certainly learned a lot from this one!
As to the subsequent clean up … less said, soonest mended!
All the best,
Bob
At first I thought "What the" ... but now I see ..
ReplyDeleteGeordie an Exiled FoG,
DeleteAt one point I did ask myself what I thought that I was doing … but then I realised and changed tack.
All the best,
Bob
Funny as the photo looks promising .. might you I may be thinking Sci-Fi!
ReplyDeleteGeordie an Exiled FoG,
DeleteIt might well be suitable for Sci-Fi, but it didn’t look like the effect I was trying to achieve.
All the best,
Bob
Oh dear , but we try these things don't we .
ReplyDeleteThe Good Soldier Svjek,
DeleteI was once told that someone who never made a mistake was someone who had probably learned very little.
All the best,
Bob
Bob,
ReplyDeleteI'd be tempted to use clumps of Linchen. Regards. KEV.
Kev Robertson (Kev),
DeleteI’ve never had much luck with lichen. I once had a batch that went mouldy and that rather put me off using it again.
All the best,
Bob
Bob, a fun experiment…and may I say it’s very commendable that you posted a report on the attempt which DIDN’T work 👍🏼. Many blogs only show the success stories, perpetuating the myth that all is perfect out there in the big, wide world. Max kudos to you, sir 🙂👍🏼.
ReplyDeleteMartin S.,
DeleteIf my mistake helps to stop someone else from doing the same, then my experiment was worth it. I agree that giving the impression that I don’t ever do something wrong is in itself wrong … and I like my regular blog readers to know that they can trust me to tell the truth on my blog.
All the best,
Bob
Hi Bob, I'd suggest including some areas of water - paint the area a muddy green-brown and gloss varnish. For the standing vegetation I'd rescue your scourer and rip it up into ragged sections and glue over most of the area. Varying the height but snipping with scissors could also help.
ReplyDeleteBrian Cameron,
DeleteThanks for the suggestion. I have - in fact - found an alternative method that works better for me, and I’ll be writing about it after Christmas.
All the best,
Bob