Whilst I was away, Andrew Rolph – the author of BARBAROSSA: KICKING IN THE DOOR and KHARKOV, MAY 1942 – THE LAST DISASTER – sent me a spare copy of E R Hooton's SPAIN IN ARMS: A MILITARY HISTORY OF THE SPANISH CIVIL WAR 1936-1939 that he had on his shelves.
The book is described as a military history, and unlike almost every other book I have read about the Spanish Civil War, it is exactly what it sets out to be. It covers the operational and strategic actions of both sides in what I found to be an easy to understand style as well as examining the evolution of the armies that took part in the war. It also gives an account of the involvement of foreign troops in the fighting and the impact that the supply of foreign military equipment had on combat.
The book is split into six chapters:
- Testing the Blades: The Madrid Front
- The New Armies
- Decision on the Northern Front
- High Tide for the Republic: Brunete and the Aragon Offensive
- The Pendulum Swings: Teruel and the Aragon Offensive
- The Last Acts: Ebro and Catalonia
I already had a Kindle copy of this book, and I did consult it during the writing of my forthcoming ¡ARRIBA ESPANA! INCLUDING THE PORTABLE SPANISH CIVIL WAR WARGAME RULES. I found it particularly helpful when I was writing the scenarios that are included in my book.
SPAIN IN ARMS: A MILITARY HISTORY OF THE SPANISH CIVIL WAR 1936-1939 was written by E R Hooton and published in 2019 by Casemate Publishers (ISBN 978 1 61200 637 6).
Hi Bob,
ReplyDeleteThe author also wrote a good account of the Balkan War as well. I shall keep an eye out for this methinks!
All the best,
DC
David Crook,
DeleteFunny that you should mention that, but I have a copy on order!
All the best,
Bob
thanks for that, I have almost bought this book a couple of times but have been put off a bit by the number of bad reviews etc. Ver useful contrast to hear from someone who's opinion is of some worth.
ReplyDeleteJohnpreece,
DeleteMy only ‘complaint’ is that the text refers to Republican formations as 78 BM (for 78th Brigade Mixta) or 11 BI (for 11th International Brigade).
I hope that you find reading the book as helpful as I did,
All the best,
Bob
Bought one!
ReplyDeleteJohnpreece,
DeleteGreat!
All the best,
Bob
Interesting. I, too, have not bought it due the fairly scathing reviews. How does it compare to Esdaile's book "The Spanish Civil war - A Military History"?
ReplyDeleteTrebian,
DeleteCharles Esdaile's book - if you can get hold of a copy at a reasonable price - is the better of the two, but at £30.00 plus for the Kindle edition and £75.00 plus for the hardback compared to just over £10.00 and £18.00 respectively for Hooton's book, the latter is good enough (and cheaper) for most wargamer's pockets ... especially if they buy my LA ULTIMA CRUZADA as well!
All the best,
Bob
I got Esdaile in paperback for less than £30, although I see that it is now a bit more pricey.
DeleteTrebian,
DeleteI have been looking for a reasonably priced second-hand copy for some time, and you did well to get a paperback copy for less than £30.00.
All the best,
Bob
Bob,
ReplyDeleteThis is a period I know little about. Inspired by your upcoming book and the above post I bought a copy today. It sounds like exactly what I would need to delve into the period.
Mark Cordone,
DeleteThe SCW is an intriguing war to study and wargame, and very little is as straightforward as it is often portrayed. For example, the Republicans were not all Communists, but a rather ragtag group of left-wingers, some centralists, and two regionalist political groups as well as the trades union. So you can have devote Roman Catholic Basque nationalists fighting alongside anti-clerical anarchists! Likewise, the Nationslists were composed of monarchists (who supported the return on Alphonso XIII, Carlists (who wanted a different branch of the Spanish Royal Family on the throne), National-Syndicalists (who had a lot in common with the anarchy-syndicalists on the other side), and the officers (and men) of the Army of Africa.
Read and enjoy!
All the best,
Bob