Pages

Monday 28 August 2023

Looking backward in order to go forward

Like most wargamers of my generation (i.e. those born during the late 1940s and early 1950s) I began my wargaming in the age of Donald Featherstone’s WAR GAMES and James Lawford’s and Peter Young’s CHARGE! I had armies of Airfix plastic figures and a collection of model vehicles manufactured by ROCO and Airfix, with air support supplied by model aircraft from Frog and Airfix. I had two main collections – American Civil War and World War II – and I fought numerous wargames with them on the floor of my shared bedroom and the living room floor and table. I eventually ended up with a green-painted pasting table … which was great for battles that could be fought on a tabletop that was approximately 2’ wide and 6’ long!

After leaving school in 1968 I bought my first metal figures from Hinton Hunt’s shop in Camden Passage. It was just after Tony Richardson’s film ‘The Charge of the Light Brigade’ was released, and I bought a number of British and Russian infantry and cavalry, which I painted (very badly) using gloss Humbrol enamel paints. (I still have some of them in storage and I really ought to strip of my awful paint job and repaint them.) I supplemented the Russian infantry with some bought from Douglas Miniatures, which were painted using Matt Humbrol enamel paints.

I studied for my Cambridge University Certificate in Education at Hockerill College of Education, Bishop’s Stortford, from 1971 to 1973, and during my time there I bought quite a few ROCO Cold War tanks and vehicles. Once I had qualified, I worked for two years at Burnt Mill Comprehensive School, Harlow, and my Cold War and World War II collections continued to expand. I did attend a few meetings of the Harlow Wargames Club, but never felt particularly welcome, and this confirmed my decision that solo wargaming was for me.

In 1975 I moved to London and began working at Woolwich Polytechnic School for Boys, Woolwich, and during my time there I was able to run an after-school wargame club which attracted a few loyal members, one of whom (Alan Abbey) I am still in regular contact with.

It was during the late 1970s that I came into contact with Eric Knowles, and for the first time I actually began to wargame as a member of a group (you could never term the collection of wargamers who met once a week in Eric’s shop’s basement as a club!) and took part in the Madasahatta Campaign … which fired my interest in colonial and World War I wargaming. In 1980 the late Paddy Griffith invited me to attend what became the first Conference of Wargamers (COW), and I’ve remained a very active member of Wargame Developments ever since, having served as the Treasurer and Membership Secretary for the last forty-three years.

By the mid 1980s I was married to Sue, and I had moved on to a new role as a Post-16 Consortium Coordinator. I was based in a number of schools in the Borough of Greenwich, and whilst I was at Thomas Tallis School, I ran a wargame option as part of their Wednesday afternoon elective studies course. It was quite a successful course (we fought an Eastern Front/Great Patriotic War mini-campaign) and I actually had one student achieve an A grade for his General Studies GCSE coursework based around a wargame that he designed.

When the Inner London Education Authority (ILEA) was wound up in 1991 I moved on to work as the Technical and Vocational Education Initiative (TVEI) coordinator and Head of Careers/Work Experience Coordinator at Crown Woods School, and I remained there as a full-time teacher until 2001. At that point my job became redundant, and I set up a teaching supply agency that provided experienced teaching staff to fill long term vacancies … and I returned to work in the IT Department at Crown Woods School for several days a week whilst also working part time for the Greenwich Education Business Partnership (GEBP). I finished my career in 2013 as a Business Studies and Travel & Tourism Lecturer at Crossways Sixth Form in Brockley, at which point I decided that forty years in teaching was enough and that it was time to retire.

During my working life I continued to wargame as and when I could and built up - and disposed of - quite a few collections. Now that I am a seventy-three-year-old, the time has come to think seriously about downsizing my collections, and recently I have been pondering the answer to the wargamer’s version of the final ‘Desert Island Discs’* question: what wargaming book and what wargame collection would you want to have with you if you were marooned on a desert island?

After considerable thought my reply would be:

  • Joseph Morschauser’s HOW TO PLAY WARGAMES MINIATURE (which just bumped Donald Featherstone’s WAR GAMES into second place).
  • My Eastern Front/Great Patriotic War collection (with my Belle Époque collection just behind it).

Writing this blog post and answering that question has helped me to identify how I now want to move forward for the foreseeable future.


* For the benefit of my non-UK blog readers, ‘Desert Island Discs’ is a BBC radio programme that has been broadcast weekly (with seasonal breaks) since 29th January 1942! The format is simple: each week a guest is invited to share a choice of the top ten records that they would like to have with them if they were castaway on a desert island. They were also entitled to chose one book (in addition to the Bible or similar religious book and the complete works of Shakespeare) and one luxury that they could take with them.

32 comments:

  1. Bob,
    It's perhaps not surprising that as we get older and take stock of our mortality, we review the accumulated stock of our hobby and wonder what we should do with it. I confess, as I begin to approach retirement I'm starting to wonder whether I will complete all the projects I have.
    Jonathan Freitag of the Palouse blog posted a question recently which is similar to yours but prompted by more dramatic circumstances, in his case wild fires and what would you save once your loved ones and pets were out of harms way?
    I find it difficult to choose just one, or even if truth be told to whittle it down to a few armies. "All of it!" is clearly not an option, which is why I suspect I'm not psychologically ready to start downsizing!
    Neil

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Neil Patterson (Neil),

      I suspect that if push ever comes to shove, I’m going to have a lot of second thoughts about what my two choices will actually be!

      At least mine is a theoretical question: Jonathan Freitag’s situation was one I would not like to ever have to face!

      As one ages, one has to face up to the fact that at some point someone is going to dispose of your collection. By taking certain decisions yourself, you will be relieving part of that stress from your executor.

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete
  2. The old wall paper pasting table was my favourite battlefield!

    I think my Desert Island Discs Wargaming Book would be (fanfare) Introduction to Battle Gaming by Terry Wise - although Featherstone's War Games was my real introduction to the hobby, Terry Wise was using the same toy soldiers as me! A grown up proper wargamer was using Airfix toy soldiers!! I would accompany this book with Airfix ACW armies.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Maudlin Jack Tar,

      I’ve used pasting tables since then for participation games that I’ve taken to shows.

      You’ve made a couple of excellent choices! A copy of Terry Wise’s book sits on my shelf of wargame books.

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete
  3. It's always interesting to see similarities... Cambridge? mine was SENCo Accreditation from the School of Education. Using wargames as a teaching aid? - Yep, GCSE English project, Redundancy? Yep, they gave all the money to the schools so I took early retirement, signed up with an agency, started the new year teaching the same kids and did that for 10 years. In 70s and downsizing my collection? - Wait a minute. Sudden stop...

    Sorry, I don't understand this downsizing concept. The things I get rid of will be exactly the same things I will want to come back to in 10 years. Still increasing my pile... it's something I have to do...

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Rob Young,

      My ‘career’ in education was exactly that: ‘to move swiftly and in an uncontrolled way’! I seemed to fall into jobs rather that seek them out. I had a lot of fun teaching, but in the end the results-driven, ‘one size fits all’, paperwork-heavy culture drove me out.

      I am sure that if I had unlimited space I’d never be thinking about downsizing, but arthritis and cancer surgery has reduced my mobility … and my toy/wargame room is on the second floor of our house. We need to move to a bungalow or two storey house … and I will need to downsize my collections in order to do so.

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete
    2. I'm luckier than you on two counts. Figures in a 16'x9' shed with a large tin structure as overflow plus mould storage. If I really, really want to I could store a lot more! My health problems cause fatigue but no pain (just some itching and coughing) or real mobility issues so generally OK there. For now. Think I've been in remission four times so far...

      Delete
    3. Rob Young,

      My toy/wargame room is about 12’ x 14’ and has to serve as my storage space as well as hold my table … which I use to paint and model on as well as fight my tabletop battles. (My table is actually two 3’ x 2’ tables pushed together. The tops can be folded over to make a 6’ x 4’ tabletop, but it’s then very difficult to get around.)

      One of the side effects of my cancer drug regime is an underactive thyroid. I do take a daily dose of Levothyroxine, but I still seem to suffer from fatigue if I do anything too strenuous. I try to exercise each day, but sometimes I doze in my armchair once I stop.

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete
  4. A long and storied career! I think my desert Island choices would be Developing the Portable Wargame, and my Risk piece armies.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mark Cordone,

      I managed to squeeze a lot into my career. (I didn’t mention that at one time I was also a part-time national and local government education advisor.)

      I cannot fault your choice of book and collection!

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete
  5. Hi Bob,
    This is a very interesting synopsis of your career- certainly vastly different to my own working life. Hope you are doing well with your radiotherapy treatment. Yes, in later years it seems to be the idea to down size our collections to concentrate on what we deem as most important to our interests. My WW2- 1/72nd Collection was sold yesterday in order to re-coup funds to pay for my DOCTOR WHO Project...not to worry as I enjoyed eight solo games of WW2 over a period of 57 days....I think Doctor WHO in 28mm is going to hold my interest for many more months to come- if not years in fact. Best Wishes - Regards. KEV.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Kev Robertson (Kev),

      Other than for a week in 2001 when I had to be unemployed to qualify for my redundancy payment, I worked continually from the age of fifteen until I retired. I even worked through my holidays whilst I was at college … and did some very unusual jobs indeed!

      I’m sorry to read that you’ve sold your WW2 collection, but I can understand why you have. I’m rather a bit of a wargaming butterfly, and I admire your singleminded approach to projects.

      All the best,

      Bob

      PS. My radiotherapy has been delayed for a day due to technical problems and won’t start until Wednesday.

      Delete
  6. I'm only 56 and I sometimes already ponder about this ;-)
    Anyway, I regularly cull my collection (not only wargaming stuff, but also books), asking "Is there any reasonable chance I will still play this game or read this book during the next year or two?" If the answer is "no", then what would change 2 years from now? 5 years? 10 years? Before I die? Why hold on to such items? Better do away with them.

    I hopefully still have a few decades to go, but at one point, I decided not to simply expand my collection, but rather "upgrade" my collection. New higher-quality stuff replaces old stuff. At least it keeps the volume under control ;-)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Phil Dutre,

      You seem to be taking a very rational and disciplined approach! My current renovation and rebasing project is enabling me to cull and upgrade my 20mm WW2 collection … although I have realised that I may have to fill a few holes.

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete
  7. I find I am thinking more about downsizing as the years pass , there are some I will never sell but some I find I never use - so they could go . The problem is I enjoy painting and collecting , but I do think twice now before a purchase and I definitely don't buy as much lead nowadays . On the desert island it would have to be Featherstone and OS ACW armies

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The Good Soldier Svjek,

      It’s very difficult to break the collecting and painting aspect of the hobby! I’m currently directing my efforts in that direction into upgrading my collections by renovating and rebasing my Belle Époque and WW2 stuff. It’s helping me to identify what I want to keep and what I can dispose of.

      Your choice of book and collection is an excellent one!

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete
  8. I have played the game of which 3 collections would you keep with a regular opponent Anthony and mine came down to:

    54mm Napoleonic
    54mm Shiny Toy Soldier
    40mm AWI

    If I had to keep one I think it would be the Napoleonic collection. My book would be Practical Wargaming by Charles Wesencraft as I have re-read it a number of times and always find it inspiring.

    Though I actually use Neil Thonas Napoleonic rules with the 54mm collection.

    I am only (!) 60 but have come to the conclusion that I can't really see me starting any more new big collections just adding to the ones I have started.

    I am thinking of clearing out some unstarted stuff (54mm Magnificent Seven) as I simply don't have the space to store the scenery required for the games and I would rather use that space for other collections scenery and figures.

    At some point we will have to downsize from this house when the garden becomes too much work and then I suspect I will have to seriously cull some of the 6000+ painted figures I have

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mike Lewis,

      That’s an interesting choice … although I’d probably have put the 54mm Shiny Toy Soldier collection at the top of the list.

      I have a copy of Charles Wesencraft’s book, having met him in in 1980 at the first ever COW. I played a game using his rules and liked how they worked. Your mention of it has reminded me that I need to re-read his book again soon.

      Our garden has a 1 in 10 slope and is already causing me difficulties. I can no longer mow the lawn (my arthritis and cancer surgery make it too difficult) and have to cut the grass using a strimmer. It’s one reason why we are thinking about moving and downsizing.

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete
    2. My very first wargaming figures were Airfix 1/32 Napoleonics that I bought aged 13 and used for Little Wars - firing Cannon and all. So there is a certain nostalgia factor about that collection.

      Delete
    3. Mike Lewis,

      I can see why you put the Napoleonics first.

      My choice of WW2 is also partly nostalgic, as my blog post shows.

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete
  9. It is a very tricky question, posed like that, because the wargaming books I might pick if I am limited to a single collection are very different to those I would pick if I am not - because (to my mind) the first question is almost synonymous with one's favourite ruleset for one's favourite period, whereas the second question more favours one of the best books about wargaming, if you see what I mean?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. JHW,

      It is a difficult question to answer … but it’s one that - in a broader sense - I have to consider when I downsize my collections. I see your problem with selecting your ‘Desert Island’ collection and wargame book … but the comments my question has generated have been very interesting.

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete
  10. This is something that I have pondered for a good few years now. The rules would be Blitzkreig Commander II and after some thought, my A Very British Civil War forces, to give me quite a broad set of gaming opportunities. I did consider NWE 1944 but have played it so much over the years, some of the gloss has worn off, but not much I hasten to add!

    In terms of downsizing, having had my brush with cancer 5 years ago, turning 60 in a few months time and a shaky painting hand, I have been giving this a lot of thought these past few years. My 18thC & 19thC ImagiNations armies will be kept (once finished of course!) and most likely my WWII and AVBCW collections. After that I'm most likely to dispose of everything else and possibly streamline my WWII forces too. Plenty to be thinking about that's for sure.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Steve J.,

      That’s a very interesting choice of book and collection … and the VBCW does have an element of 20th imagi-nation to it.

      My Belle Époque 19th century imagi-nation collection is certainly more portable than my WW2 one … partially due to it being 15mm rather than 20mm and therefore lighter to carry.

      It sounds as if you have a very sensible plan … and keeping part of your WW2 collection gets my vote!

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete
  11. Bob -
    Like you, I have been finding that passing the big seven-zero does bring one up against an uneasy sense of mortality. I rather think at this point, though, that it would be hard to dispose of any of my armies. Those that would go first would be my least developed: Wars of the Roses, 30YW, my DBA Romans ... a mere drop in the ocean. Possibly my small BMC Yorktowns 'collection', and my Army Men (Jono's World) - but I'd keep the navies.

    What I'd certainly keep are my ACW, Napoleonics, WW2, 18th Century, and 19th Century 'Chromatic Wars' armies. There is a another collection that would probably have to go: My WSS Imperialists and the WSS starter army. Oh, yes, I nearly forgot my 15mm Byzantines and enemies... H'mmm. That ought to tell me something...

    Having said that, I should probably begin 'preparing for sale' any collections I might consider disposing of, and that would mean having to 'finish' them.

    Books. Of course, I would have to keep my 'Portable Wargames' library, along with 'A Winterish War' and 'Trouble in Zubia'. I'd keep my copy of Featherstone's 'War Games' (probably the first war game book I read), Young and Lawford's 'Charge!' (the first war game book I owned) and Charles Grant's 'The War Game' (the inspiration for what my 18th Century armies were to become). For historiography, probably my 'Battles and Leaders of the Civil War' would be the last to go, and it would be hard to part with Runciman's 'Crusades', Col Henderson's biography of Stonewall Jackson, and Major-General F. W. von Mellenthin's 'Panzer Battles'... and J.F.C. Fuller's 'Decisive Battles of the Western World' ...

    I probably ought to do a proper inventory of my stuff. I don't always know what I've got.

    I don't think I much like growing old(er)...
    Cheers,
    Ion

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Archduke Piccolo (Ion),

      I agree about not enjoying the growing older aspect of life very much! With it comes lots of decisions one would rather not want to have to make.

      You seem to have a far larger and more eclectic number of collections than I have, and that would make choosing which to keep and which to get rid of much more difficult. It's almost as if each additional collection increases the problems by at least 50%.

      Likewise with your books. I've been weeding mine out for some time, but each time that I do, the remaining rump becomes less easy to prune. I am certainly going to hang on to as many as my bookshelves can accommodate, and especially those books which have had a meaningful influence on my wargaming ... such as WAR GAMES and CHARGE!

      Like you, I really ought to produce an proper inventory of what I have. Even yesterday I found something in a box that I had completely forgotten that I owned, and its rediscovery will impact on my current project.

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete
  12. Hello Bob. that's an interesting run down on your career and Desert Island Wargames. You're a close contemporary of my brother-in-law who also worked for ILEA and then Greenwich LEA after ILEA was abolished, though in a non-teaching role.
    Having rehearsed the collection question on Jonathon Freitag's blog, I already know I'd keep my SYW armies (though I make a case for keeping my whole collection because of the small space they occupy). I haven't given any thought to which books yet - though Christopher Duffy's work will figure prominently in the final selection! As for downsizing, whilst at 60 I'm increasingly conscious of mortality, I am putting off thought of that. For now.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nundanket,

      I'm glad that enjoyed reading about my career and thoughts about what my 'Desert Island' wargaming choices would be. I suspect that I might know your brother-in-law (the ILEA and Greenwich LEA were quite small organisations in many ways), but I won't ask his name.

      Does the SYW lend itself to small collections? I have the impression that it can do ... and one can hardly fault your choice of Duffy's books. They were amongst some of the best on that period that I have read/.

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete
  13. How interesting! I shall have to have a gander at Morschauser’s book now. As for me, I'd be tempted to take my copy of Blitzkrieg Commander II as it has unit stats for pretty much every theatre and faction of WWII. I could use it as a reference for whatever game I dreamt up. That should keep me busy for a while. Collections-wise, I guess a set of blocks might be the most versatile, though not very exciting. Though that's where my imagination would kick in, one hopes!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Donjondo,

      I thoroughly recommend Morschauser’s book. In many ways, it was far ahead of its time.

      Blocks are certainly very versatile, and although I prefer to use miniatures for my games, I have used coloured blocks and games that use them.

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete
    2. Well I'm pleased to say that his book is winging its way to me as we speak. Along with a 2nd copy of one of yours for a friend who I've recently converted to the joys of Portable Wargaming! :) Yes I agree, as my lead mountain too testifies.

      Delete
    3. Donjondo,

      That’s great news! I hope that your friend enjoys using my PW rules.

      My own lead pile is gradually getting smaller as I have begun the slow process of downsizing my collections.

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete

Thank you for leaving a comment. Please note that any comments that are spam or contain phishing messages or that come from Google Accounts that are 'Unknown' will be deleted.