Pages

Wednesday, 23 October 2024

Some new books added to my library

Over the past week or so I’ve taken delivery of three books that filled definite holes in my naval history library. They are:

  • THE WINDFALL BATTLESHIPS: AGINCOURT, CANADA, ERIN, EAGLE AND THE BALKAN & LATIN-AMERICAN ARMS RACES
  • BRITISH BATTLESHIPS OF THE VICTORIAN ERA
  • BRITISH CRUISERS OF THE VICTORIAN ERA

These books were recommended tome by the naval historian Toby Ewin and my fellow blogger David Crook … and they are excellent!


THE WINDFALL BATTLESHIPS: AGINCOURT, CANADA, ERIN, EAGLE AND THE BALKAN & LATIN-AMERICAN ARMS RACES

The book's contents are as follows:

  • Preface
  • Introduction
  • Abbreviations and Conventions
  • 1. August 1914 and Beyond
  • 2. The Latin-American Connection
  • 3. The Balkan Connection
  • 4. With the Grand Fleet
  • 5. Alternative Service: Erin, Canada, and Agincourt
  • 6. Alternative Service: Eagle
  • 7. Ends and New Beginnings
  • 8. The Ageing Queens of Latin America
  • 9. Retrospect
  • Appendix: Warships Under Construction for Foreign Customers in August 1914
  • Notes
  • Bibliography
  • Index

This is a very comprehensive history of the naval arms races that were taking place in the Balkans and Latin America during the early years of the twentieth century and is lavishly illustrated with photographs and line drawings of the ships. many of the latter were drawn by John Jordan and Ian Sturton, both of whom are well-known to students of naval history.

I am very glad that I have added this book to my collection ... and in my opinion, the appendix alone was worth what I paid for the book. It lists the seventy-six warships being built in France, Germany, Italy, the United Kingdom, and the United States for Austria-Hungary, Argentina, Brazil, Chile, Germany, Greece, Japan, the Netherlands, Norway, Portugal, Romania, Russia, and Turkey, and records their ultimate fates.


BRITISH BATTLESHIPS OF THE VICTORIAN ERA

The book's contents are as follows:

  • List of Abbreviations
  • Acknowledgements
  • 1. British Strategy And The Admiralty
  • 2. Revolutions In Ship design
  • 3. Racing The French
  • 4. The Reed Era: Monster Guns
  • 5. The Captain Disaster And The Committee On Designs
  • 6. A New Kind Of Warship
  • Colour Section: Original Admiralty Draughts
  • 7. The Naval Defence Act
  • 8. A Continuing Programme
  • 9. The Export Market
  • 10. The Victorian Battle Fleet At Sea
  • Notes
  • bibliography
  • Ship Data
  • Ship List
  • Index

Any book covering the history and development of British battleships is inevitably going to be compared with the book written by the late Dr Oscar Parkes. His book BRITISH BATTLESHIPS: WARRIOR, 1860 TO VANGUARD, 1950. A HISTORY OF DESIGN, CONSTRUCTION AND ARMAMENT is regarded by many – me included – as the definitive source of information about the subject. So. how do the two books compare?

Well, in my opinion, BRITISH BATTLESHIPS OF THE VICTORIAN ERA tells the history of the development of the British battleship during that period rather well indeed. It is well illustrated, and I especially liked the fold-out colour section in the middle of the book. It is also a somewhat lighter tome and easier to read when seated in one's favourite armchair, although I did find some of the type rather small. It is also available to buy for less than £20.00 on the second-hand market whereas the cheapest price I could find for Dr Parkes's book was £45.00 ... and the most expensive was in excess of £200.00!


BRITISH CRUISERS OF THE VICTORIAN ERA

The book's contents are as follows:

  • Acknowledgements
  • Illustrator's Notes
  • Introduction
  • 1. Steam, Sail and Wooden Hulls
  • 2. Iron Hulls
  • 3. The First Armoured Cruisers
  • 4. Fast Steel Cruisers
  • 5. Torpedo And Small Cruisers
  • 6. Big Cruisers To Protect Commerce
  • 7. The Fast Wing Of The Battle Fleet
  • Appendix: Vickers Designs
  • 8. Epilogue: Fisher's Revolution
  • Bibliography
  • Notes
  • Data List (Specifications)
  • List Of Ships
  • Abbreviations
  • Index

The steam-powered cruiser was the equivalent of the frigate that was used during the Age of Sail. They were designed and built to serve a variety of purposes, ranging from showing the flag to protecting the nation's commerce from attacks by enemy warships. Some were even destined to form part of the main battle fleet where they were destined to serve as scouts and to even engage enemy heavy units.

This book tells the story of the development of the British cruiser from its earliest days until the First World War. It is well illustrated with photographs and line drawings and describes in some detail each of the classes and types of cruiser that were built. It also covers the designs built for foreign navies – such as the heavily-armed and fast Elswick-built cruisers – that influenced the development of the British cruisers.

Although it was written and published before Dr Friedman's book about British battleships, it is an excellent companion publication and one that I have no hesitation in recommending.


THE WINDFALL BATTLESHIPS: AGINCOURT, CANADA, ERIN, EAGLE AND THE BALKAN & LATIN-AMERICAN ARMS RACES was written by Professor Aidan Dodson and published in 2023 by Seaforth Publishing (ISBN 978 1 3990 6322 7).

BRITISH BATTLESHIPS OF THE VICTORIAN ERA was written by Norman Friedman and published in 2018 by Seaforth Publishing (ISBN 978 1 5267 0325 5).

BRITISH CRUISERS OF THE VICTORIAN ERA was written by Norman Friedman (with drawings by A B Baker III) and published in 2012 by Seaforth Publishing (ISBN 978 1 8483 2099 4).

12 comments:

  1. The 'Windfall...' book is excellent as a history of the lesser known navies and also of the proposed designs offered by exporters of the period. The idea of Agincourt with seven single 15" gun turrets is quite a thought.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Nigel Dury,

      I agree …. it is a very informative book.

      The various design options make interesting comparisons with the some of the freelance ‘stock’ battleship designs that were offered to overseas navies by Vickers and Armstrongs.

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete
  2. Bob,

    I strongly second your recommendation of Mr Friedman's two books. I had not previously come across the third title, but it is now on my Amazon Wishlist, so I'm expecting to get it by Christmas at the latest.

    Compared with my youth it feels that we are living in a golden age for students of naval history. When I was a teenager there used to be a fair number of books on major battles but relatively little on the ships themselves. (There were Ian Allen's little booklets of course, and titles like Parkes, but this latter was way out of my price range and at one time I could only access it in the reference section of Croydon Library.)

    At least that's how it felt to me at the time – in those pre Internet days it was not easy to even discover that a book of interest existed, so I probably simply missed things through ignorance. Now there are so many interesting titles that my limitations are finance and reading times,

    Mike

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Mike Hall,

      I think that you are right about the range of naval history books written these days. There do seem to be far more about these days and they don’t all trot out the same old (and often incorrect) data.

      I have almost the whole range of Ian Allen books that cover the navies of the First and Second World Wars … and I still use them. The little paperback versions are long gone from my collection, but I’ve replaced them with the hardback editions.

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete
  3. Hello there Bob,

    I knew you would like the ‘Windfall’ title - it is a cracker and I reckon that Eric would have been hugely inspired by it! Plenty of potential for Portable Navies of an imaginary kind.

    The other two are also excellent with plenty of really good photos.

    I am pleased you like all three of these and am keen to hear what plans you have as a result!

    All the best,

    DC

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. David Crook,

      The ‘Windfall’ book is much more extensive in its coverage than its title suggests. I only wish that I’d had it when I wrote my book about the Balkan Wars.

      The other two books supplement the books that already adorn my bookshelves, and the illustrations and plans are very, very useful.

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete
  4. Definitely interested in the 19th-century ones. I've always wanted to try the 1875 naval rules from Featherstone's Naval Wargames, but finding models and stats for the period between ACW and Pre-dreadnoughts is pretty difficult.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Jennifer,

      There are some paper side-on views of some ironclads on the JuniorGeneral.org website (https://juniorgeneral.org/index.php/figure/figureList/19thcentury).

      I would also recommend David Crook’s blog (http://awargamingodyssey.blogspot.com/) where he is currently blogging a series about how he builds model ironclads.

      DM me if there’s anything specific I can help you with.

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete
    2. Will definitely check out that blog, thanks. I did pick up a knife and some balsa, oh, ages ago, on a whim to try building something of my own.

      I did use some of the Junior General Lissa models in my first runthroughs of the rules; the later types are generally very, very small.

      I got your email, thanks!

      Delete
    3. Aha, found both the Victorian volumes on the Hoopla library app! Alas, more to read ...

      Delete
    4. Jennifer,

      Try building your own models if you can. Most of them are fairly basic in outline and are quite simple to model.

      All the best,

      Bob

      PS. I’m glad that you like what I sent you.

      Delete
    5. Jennifer,

      Now that you have access to them, I expect to hear that you’ve carved your own fleet of ships in the near future!

      All the best,

      Bob

      Delete

Thank you for leaving a comment. Please note that any comments that are spam or contain phishing messages or that come from Google Accounts that are 'Unknown' will be deleted.