Regular blog readers might find some of what follows covers things that I have previously written about on my blog, but for completeness – and to help me to clarify my own thinking – I have written about how I arrived at the situation I find myself in today.
When I retired in 2014, I had visions of spending loads of time wargaming and doing wargame-related activities ... interspersed – of course – with going on cruises, doing the usual round of household chores, and fitting in all the other things that normal life demands.
In anticipation of this, during the early years of the new century we spent quite a lot on money converting our house's loft into an home office, a shower room, and what became my toy/wargame room, and for the first years on my retirement I was able to use the latter almost every day.
Then real life made itself felt. A simple test showed signs of blood in my faeces, and on investigation it was discovered that I had a small cancerous polyp in my intestines. At the height of the COVID-19 pandemic I went into hospital to have a minor keyhole surgical procedure to remove it. The operation did not go according to plan and I ended up with what turned out to be an irreversible colostomy.
Two years later, what I thought was a minor problem with my urinary system turned out to be prostate cancer ... and since then I've undergone chemotherapy, radiotherapy, and surgery. The cancer is still there, but it is under control and does not seem to be getting any worse.
Now, these two cancers rather took the wind out of my wargaming sails, but I carried on as best I could. I found things a bit more difficult as I was spending lots of time either undergoing treatment or tests, but what time I was able to devote to my hobby was very enjoyable ... and then I broke my right leg, just above the ankle.
I had been experiencing problems with my legs for many years, but by 2024 they had become very weak and climbing the stairs to my toy/wargame room was sometimes very difficult. On the evening of 10th April, I stood up from a living room chair in order to go to bed, and as I walked forward, my right leg gave way and my fall broke my leg.
What followed was nearly three weeks in hospital and then twenty-two weeks confined to bed at home. For the first sixteen weeks, my axonal polyneuropathy – the cause of my weakness – had left me unable to walk, let alone climb the stairs up to my toy/wargame room. At the time, the prognosis was that I would probably be confined to a wheelchair and not walk again, but thanks to the Royal Greenwich Reablement Team and six weeks of intensive physiotherapy was not only able to stand again on my own two legs – with the aid of a walking frame and walking sticks – but actually begin to learn how to climb up a flight of stairs.
Twenty-five weeks after I had broken my leg, we had a stairlift installed, and on 2nd October I was able to use it to go up to bed the first time in nearly six months ... and a visit to my toy/wargame room soon followed.
It soon became apparent that it was very unlikely that I was going to be able to fulfill my dreams of wargaming as much as I had hoped when I retired. Just getting upstairs – even using the stairlift – was tedious and very restricting. If I went up there, I felt marooned ... and if I didn't go up, I felt cheated of the enjoyment I get from wargaming. This dilemma has hung around every since, and every attempt I have made to find a solution has not exactly been a failure but has proved unsatisfactory.
This is where I now find myself ... and until I can find a workable solution, I cannot seem to make significant progress. This is not to say that things have been in a state of limbo; I've been working on my Belle Époque project and I've been gaming on a regular basis at Dice on the Hill. I've also been playing around with a new version of my PORTABLE WARGAME rules for use with my Belle Époque project and trying to devise a set of campaign maps for this project.
So, what do I need to do? I need to create a truly portable wargame that is light and small enough so that I can either bring downstairs and set it up on our dining table or that I can set up on the worktable in my toy/wargame room. I have the figures, I have the draft of a set of rules that might be suitable, and I have loads of Hexon II terrain ... but the latter is not as portable as I need.
I’ve been playing around with possible alternatives to the Hexon II … and I am giving serious consideration to using either a square gridded cloth or board. The choice of squares makes sense for several reasons:
- Late nineteenth century warfare tended to be linear in nature, and using a square grid reflects this.
- It is easy to mark up a cloth or board with a square grid.
- It harks back to games like Joseph Morschauser's FRONTIER and Dr. David Charles Ballinger Griffith’s POLEMOS.
At present I am looking at using 5cm x 5cm (2-inch x 2-inch) squares. I've used this size of grid square in the past (e.g. The Attack on Morobad) ...
The Attack on Morobad. It used a 12 x 12 grid of 5cm x 5cm (2-inch x 2-inch) squares on a sand-coloured felt cloth. The Great Wall of Morobad was homemade from wooden Jenga blocks mounted on 5cm x 5xm MDF squares and the palm trees were mounted on bases made from Fimo.
... and an 8 x 8 grid would be 40cm x 40cm (16-inches x 16-inches) and a 12 x 12 grid would be 60cm x 60cm (24-inches x 24-inches). Both of these would be ideal for my requirements.
Another advantage of using this size of grid square is that my existing Belle Époque collection is mounted on 4cm-wide MDF bases (Infantry on 4cm x 2cm, cavalry on 4cm x 3cm, and artillery on 4cm x 4cm bases) that fit inside this size of grid square. In addition, I will be able to mount terrain on 5cm x 5cm MDF squares (or multiples thereof), of which I have a plentiful supply.
This is the current state-of-play with regard to my plans to create a truly portable wargame that I can easily carry up and down stairs from my toy/wargame room or fit on my worktable. Now all I have to do is to get hold of a suitably-sized piece of felt material or board ... and then I can start being creative.
Bob, that is such a pity after you had got things so well organised! However, I think that it is great that you are making the best of the situation.
ReplyDeleteAs regards your future games, I have a suggestion - what about a PW board like the one that I made, with modular tiles? That would be easy to do with some of the laser-cut mdf or plywood squares that are readily available online? I you went for either 2 out or 3 out square, it would fit on a collapsible card table unite easily. If you think that would be an idea, I am very happy to help.
Regards
Ian
Ian Dury,
DeleteCheers! Funnily enough, I have been giving serious thought to producing a PW board like yours (I have a photo of it as my screensaver!) ... and for the reasons you state in your comment. I particularly like the idea of using a collapsible card table as I could also use it when I want to do some work on my laptop.
All the best,
Bob
Do you have suitable board to put the modular tiles on? - If not, I may still have a spare 3' x 3' plywood board tucked away....
DeleteIan Dury,
DeleteThanks for your very kind offer. I think that I have a suitable board in our storage unit ... which I hope to visit tomorrow. If I can't find it there, I may well get back to you.
All the best,
Bob
Bob,
ReplyDeleteAs I child my playing space was the table in the living room so games had to be over before the next meal! Short, fun little games became the norm - not that I had the money for larger games anyway. In my old age now (!) I have returned to this ethos, not least because large rule books are beyond my aging brain and eyes these days! If a game is over quickly, one can always play a second or even third!
Wishing you all the best
Steve
Steve,
DeleteMy first wargames were fought on the floor of the sitting room in our family home, followed by a painting table in a shared bedroom (which resulted in very long and very thin tabletop battlefields!).
When I retired, I bought two IKEA dining tables that had swivel, folded tops. Folded, they give a playing surface that is 3' x 4'; unfolded, the tabletop measures 4' x 6'. The only problem is that I also use it as a worktable and - if it is unfolded - I now cannot get around it due to my mobility problems!
As to modern rulebooks ... well, once you take out all the wonderful wargaming 'porn' images (i.e. the photographs of incredibly well painted figures on exquisitely modelled terrain) and then the painting guides etc., there often seems to be very basic rules that are made complicated by to loads of caveats (e.g. 'When Medium Heavy Light cavalry in double line are charging stationary Light Medium Heavy cavalry that are in column ...'.
Why can't they just keep things simple and to the point?
All the best,
Bob
Thank you for writing this. You are an inspiration and a hero.
DeleteMichael Taylor,
DeleteThank you for your kind and fulsome words. I am very humbled by them.
All the best,
Bob
BOB,
ReplyDeleteIt really sounds like you have rounded down the whole project- what color are you choosing for the Felt? Regards. KEV.
Kev Robertson (Kev),
DeleteIt took me a lot of time and thinking to get where I am ... but I think that I might be about to crack the problem! As to the felt I will use ... well, I'll probably opt for a sand-coloured one as shown in the photographs of the Attack on Morobad. I can always get a green one later.
All the best,
Bob
Bob, kudos to you for overcoming all difficulties you have faced over the last few years! For what it's worth, I love small, fast games. As a result I have ended up playing my current hybrid 3x3/Dominion rules. My battlefields are 8.5 x 11 cardstock with mini armies of around a dozen units.
ReplyDeleteFor a good combination of appearance and portability I think felt is the way to go. In the past I have experimented with using dots to mark the corners of squares with very good results.
Best of luck with your new project, I'm looking forward to reading the rules, and maybe adapting them for 3x3/Dominion! 😁
Mark Cordone,
DeleteMy wife would probably say that I've overcome my difficulties thanks to her support (which is very true!) and my own sheer bloody-mindedness!
I've found the armies that you've produced over the years very inspirational, and I did give serious thought to just sticking to a simple 3 x 3 gridded layout ... but although I have had great fun fighting a Napoleonic campaign on such a grid, I really want to give myself the option to have a bit more space on my tabletop so that I can manoeuvre my troops a bit more before they come to blows.
If I don't use a felt cloth with dots or crosses to mark the grid square corners, I'll probably use squares of MDF on a board to create my tabletop battlefield. I need to do a bit more experimentation, but I am narrowing down the options.
All the best,
Bob
Bob - I've been using 1.5 inch squares for small games (with 10mm figures) as this means an 8x8 grid can fit on a foot square board, which is a very convenient size . Of course, your unit bases may not easily fit this size. 6 inch square mdf (I got mine cut by Warbases) are also a nice option for an easily set up board - a 2 inch per square grid would work nicely on these. Hope you get gaming again soon.
ReplyDeleteAll the best.
Maudlin Jack Tar,
DeleteIf I had gone down the 10mm rather than 15mm route for my armies, I think that I would also have opted for something about 1.5-inches or 40mm for the squares. The latter are a bit larger ... but not too much so.
If I do opt for MDF squares, Warbases will be the place I'll go to buy them. Their service is second-to-none and the products are always excellent.
All the best,
Bob
While my circumstances are different, I have gone through similar thought processes recently.
ReplyDeleteFor practical reasons, the foreseeable future confines me to a 3' x 2' gaming area, hence digging out the 15mm DBA armies and looking at 1:285 WW2 and pausing work on larger scales.
Sometimes practicality overules desire.
Neil
Neil Patterson (Neil),
DeleteThe maximum size of tabletop currently available to me is 3' x 2' so I know exactly the sort of limitations you are having to work with.
Although I am not a great fan of DBA and its derivatives, they work well for those wargamers with restricted space, and the joy of them is that with an average of 12 units per side, it does not cost a fortune or take years to create enough armies to have lots of choice and fun. (As an aside, when Phil Barker played an early version of PW at COW one year, he told me afterwards that he wished that he had used a gridded tabletop when he designed DBA!)
I recently went to our storage unit and realised that I have two large Really Useful Boxes full of 1:87th-scale ROCO models. I have no idea if I will ever use them, but I cannot bring myself to get rid of them.
All the best,
Bob
I think you have done very well. You have authored a much-loved set of rules which people use both as they are and as a starting point for their own mods; you are a respected wargame voice, with a huge wealth of knowledge; you have a marvellous collection of figures and terrain; and you are at the centre of the blogging community. And this is all while dealing with health issues!
ReplyDeleteI am sure that you will have success in your new project as you have had had success in all others. And by 'success' of course, we wargamers mean we start something, finish part of it, imagine grand expansions we don't quite get to, then move onto something else :D
Keep on keepin' on, Bob.
Cheers,
Aaron
Prufrock (Aaron),
DeleteThank you for your very kind words. They are greatly appreciated, especially at a time when I am trying to get my thoughts and ideas into some sort of coherent form.
What you write about never actually quite finishing a project is very true. There are very few wargamers who - like Thistlebarrow of Napoleonic Wargaming - can actually be single-minded enough to stick to one period and one figure scale ... and even he seems to like to tinker with his rules periodically to see if he can improve them.
Long live the butterfly wargaming mind!
All the best,
Bob
Hello Bob. I am glad you are feeling better, although feeling cut off from your lofty games room. I believe much the same happened to Donald Featherstone in his later years with his legendary games loft.
ReplyDeleteUsing a noticeboard or picture frame (which can be stored out of the way or hung picture frame style on a wall when not in use) or two smaller hex boards box lids worked for me with my small amount of space and no permanent gaming table.
Here are the box lid hex grids:
https://manoftinblog.wordpress.com/2016/09/28/my-portable-hex-games-board/
And on a larger scale, admittedly also hexes rather than grid squares:
https://manoftinblog.wordpress.com/2017/08/01/192-hexes-of-joy-a-larger-hex-game-board/
Mark, Man of TIN,
DeleteI didn't know that about Donald Featherstone. It makes me feel a lot better about my own problems accessing my toy/wargame room.
I am going to our local IKEA later this week, and if I cannot find the MDF board that I think is in our storage unit, I'll take a look at the picture frame that they stock.
I remember your hex boards very well indeed. It was very impressive and showed just how much one can achieve in a small space.
All the best,
Bob
Hi Bob, I have read your blog for a few years without commenting before. I just wanted to suggest "Travel Battle" by Perry Miniatures ( although I not sure they still make it). It is available online if you google it. It may be what you are looking for. Best Wishes, Andy
ReplyDeleteBusrider53 (Andy),
DeleteThanks for reminding me about TRAVEL BATTLE. I actually own two of them and they are in our storage unit ... and had forgotten about them!
Please feel free to comment again.
All the best,
Bob
Pitty the last few years hasn't been 'a walk in the park'. Despite this I think you've done the very best out of it Bob, regarding both wargaming and railway modelling. Keeping it small and manageable seems to be a good plan. I'm grateful for you've kept posting on you blog, sharing your wisdom and inspiration for others. I wish you the best, and I'm looking forward to see what you make of your truly portable wargame.
ReplyDeleteRoger,
DeleteCheers! I’ve done my best to overcome my recent difficulties … with the massive support and help of my wife and friends.
The comments I’ve received to this blog post have been very helpful and I’ve got lots of ideas that I can pursue.
I have every intention of continuing to blog and write for as long as I am able to … and I hope that you’ll continue to read my blog and make comments.
All the best,
Bob
More interesting thoughts Bob. I also mainly end up playing on the dining table, and while my circumstances are different, for quick (eg Dominion) games, a small base cloth works very well. I can just sort everything I need into one box (including dice, terrain etc) and carry it all down in one go. I find a few bursts of spray paint transform a bit of felt too.
ReplyDeleteMartin Rapier,
DeleteYour ‘one box’ is the sort of thing that I hope to replicate. That way I can easily carry it down to the ground floor from my toy/wargame room on my stairlift.
I like the idea of using spray paint to break up the uniformity of a felt cloth. It’s something I can try when the weather improved.
All te best,
Bob
Bob -
ReplyDeleteYour toughest campaign has been - and remains - a struggle with your health and fitness. Every now and then, I guess, one has according to circumstance to reappraise one's agenda. Real life has a way of intruding upon one's other plans.
But all this time, your own projects have been an inspiration to me. Now, I have a plethora of playing surfaces from which to choose: from a rather heavy 6'x4' board I can mount on trestles, to my well-used 4'4"x4' hex board, my 10x10 square grid (4" squares), and various boards of smaller physical dimensions with smaller grid cells. I have also a green blanket (that I've had for well over 40 years and use more for ironing), a bed cover that has faded from its original chocolate brown to something nearer tan, a tan blanket, and a pale beige bedspread that I liberated from an earthquake stricken hotel about 14 years ago.
I sure lord spoiled myself for choice there!
Having said that, apart from my 15mm 'Byzantines and Friends' nearly all my armies are in the range 23-28mm metals and plastics. And some have been based according to a scheme that I adopted long before I found Portable Wargames (or they found me).
So one adapts. I have even a 3X3 board for land warfare and another (a kitchen benchtop off cut) for naval. Oh, yeah - and a meter square of artificial grass that I've hardly ever used...
So, in respect of having smaller spaces available (including the kitchen table itself, though that usually holds my hex-board and my 10x10 grid.
My armies and other war games impedimenta are scattered through several rooms, mostly my bedroom, but quite a bit in this 'office' area, where I set up my 6x4 board.
My favourites, though, is my 15x12 hex board, and, for my mini-Chubby naval the twin hex-board I made a year of so ago.
My main regret is that I am pretty nearly forced to use the kitchen table as my wargames venue. Not that we use the table all that often for meals...
I'm always interested to see how your projects develop -
All the best.
Ion
Archduke Piccolo (Ion),
DeleteWow! That is quite some collection of different playing surfaces!
I’ve always liked your home-made hex and square gridded boards. They always look very impressive in your wargames and show that it is possible for anyone - including me - to create their own such boards.
I must admit, that if I had been starting from scratch, I would have used 20mm figures - preferable Jacklex - for my Belle Époque project. It is the size of figure that I started out proper wargaming with (Good old Airfix!) and it’s the size that I still use for my Eastern Front/Great Patriotic War collection.
We don’t have a kitchen table … but we do have a dining table that seats six and a small two-seater glass-topped table in our conservatory. We use the latter for most of our meals … and having just measured it, I could easily fit a 2’ x 2’ board on top of it.
All the best,
Bob
You do seem to be looking at a 2 area gaming setup... with a dining room table 'kit' as well as an upstairs setup when feeling a bit better. Certainly the dining room table has been used as the main table for a lot of people over the years.
ReplyDeleteRob Young,
DeleteYou’ve summed up the situation very well indeed. The only drawback with using the dining table is that there isn’t a lot of room to get around it.
All the best,
Bob
Hi Bob
ReplyDeleteI have been following your blog, and consequently your health problems, for some time. But even so reading a summary brings home to me what a difficult few years you have experienced. It says a lot for your determination that you have refused to give in to this run of bad luck and just feel sorry for yourself.
Our approach to wargaming could hardly be more different. However I have always admired your wide range of interests and your enthusiasm each time you move on to a new project. Also the fact that you do not abandon old projects, but sooner or later return to them with renewed enthusiasm.
I have often thought that your wide range of interests, your very successful rule books and your regular blogging must play a very large part in being able to put aside life's many, and serious, problems. I am not a religious man, but I imagine that a strong faith must bring similar support in difficult times.
I would not be at all concerned that you have discovered another obstacle to your retirement wargame plans, I am pretty sure that it is those very obstacles that keep you going.
I am sure that I am not alone in saying that your determination to pursue a happy retirement, despite all of the obstacles, has been an inspiration. And I am also certain that sharing your many very real difficulties with such honesty helps your readers to put their own problems into perspective and realise that the glass really is half full rather than half empty.
best regards
Paul
Thistlebarrow (Paul),
DeleteThank you for your very insightful comment.
I suspect that my attitude to life was ingrained into me by my parents and grandparents. My father was a member of 6th Airborne Division during the Second World War and always had a very ‘can do’ attitude. Problems and obstacles were things to be overcome … and when a situation required a ‘fight or flight’ response, the reaction was always to fight!
There are times when I really envy your ability to single-mindedly concentrate on just one historical period … and coming to it rather late in my wargaming life, I can easily understand why wargaming the Napoleonic Wars has exercised some much attraction to you and Jan, and given you so many years of enjoyment.
I am not a regular churchgoer, although I do believe that something makes our universe work. That said, I had a Christian upbringing, and try to live in accordance with its principles as well as the tenets of Freemasonry … an organisation of which I am still an active member.
Back in the early 1980s, I had a breakdown brought on by overwork and stress … and not enough wargaming! Part of my treatment was learning to write about the things that happen to me, and my blog is in part a result of me continuing to do this. I also think that by telling people that serious illness does not have to result in isolation or one becoming too inward looking might help someone who finds themselves in a similar situation. As far as I am concerned, if I manage to offer hope to just one person, then the effort has been more than worth it.
I have no idea what the future may hold for me, but one thing I am sure about: I’ll be wargaming for as long as I am able to push a stand of figures across a tabletop!
All the best,
Bob
Let me first say that now that I'm going through some of the things you have you are an inspiration to me on many levels.
ReplyDeleteAs for solutions to limited space and potability whether you choose a cloth, Hexon, or individual terrain tiles, simply craft your rules to the space you have. Having spent years playing on 11"x 17" maps you can get a lot of terrain in a small area. I have admired your creativity for years and I'm sure you will come up with a great solution.
For myself getting figures out and playing is the best medicine. Your Portable Wargame rules in there varies incarnation have been my solo games solution for years.
Thank you.
WEK 3,
DeleteI hope that you are not finding life too difficult to deal with. There are days when I really find it difficult to motivate myself to get out of bed ... but I've found that if I make the effort, I soon find myself feeling more positive.
Thanks for the feedback about your own experience with wargaming in a small space. It's all very helpful and will assist me to find a solution.
I am very pleased to read that you've found my rules helpful and that they've been helping you to fight lots of solo wargames.
All the best,
Bob
There is something to be said for "sheer bloody mindedness". ha ha
ReplyDeleteBut seriously, sounds like you are looking at making the best of things, with practical solutions, as you are wont to do. Even though life tosses in monkey wrenches.
Best wishes!
Fitz-Badger,
DeleteThere's a line in one of my favourite poems (Norman and the Saxon by Rudyard Kipling) has a line that sums it up very well: 'When he stands like an ox in the furrow – with his sullen set eyes on your own,
And grumbles, 'This isn't fair dealing,' my son, leave the Saxon alone.' I am that Saxon ... although - in truth - I am of mixed Saxon and Norman heritage!
I am striving to find a solution ... and several possibilities have emerged, thanks to the ideas and comment from regular blog readers like you.
All the best,
Bob
Despite all the health issues I am glad you still have the fortitude to carry on gaming.
ReplyDeleteI have spent the last 14 years mostly playing on 2'x2' or smaller tables using 6mm or 15mm ancients or 6mm WW2 figures. Loads of rules work on this small scale so I am sure you will have no trouble. I have gradually moved a lot towards grids and have about half a dozen different grid boards! I wish you luck in finding what works for you.
Shaun Travers,
DeleteCheers! Do I have fortitude? Possibly ... but I have also heard it called sullen stupidity!
Half a dozen different grid boards! My first thought was 'that's a lot ... and then I realised that I probably have as many if not more!
Thanks for your comment. It is always great to get comments from regular blog readers.
All the best,
Bob