At long last (but ahead of schedule!) Henry Hyde’s WARGAMING CAMPAIGNS has been published.
I had pre-ordered mine from Amazon, but when I realised that it has just been published by Pen & Sword and was on sale directly from them for less than Amazon’s discounted price, I cancelled my order with Amazon and bought a copy from the publisher. It arrived a couple of days later, and since then I’ve been dipping in and out of it.
The book a forward by Brigadier (Ret’d) Charles S Grant OBE, a preface, and fourteen chapters. The latter are:
- An Introduction to Campaigns: Starting at the Beginning
- Campaign Generalship: Mastering strategy
- March to Glory: Campaign Rules for All Ages
- Where Are We Going?: Creating maps for your forces to fight over
- With or Without Umpires – or Opponents: The Role of the Umpire and Solo Campaigns
- We the People: Personality Driven Campaigns
- Skirmish and Roleplaying Campaigns: You don’t need thousands of troops to play campaigns
- Whether the Weather May Be Wet or Fine … : Considerations of climate in wargame campaigns
- War at Sea: Naval aspects of campaigns
- Air Power: Adding aerial warfare to campaigns
- Digital Campaigns: Making use of modern technology
- Making Campaigns Work: The Wars of the Faltenian Succession
- Standing on the Shoulders of Giants: Learning from well-known wargame campaigns
- All Roads lead to Rome: The sheer variety of ideas for campaigns
Since it arrived, I have spent many hours reading this book, and I have come to the conclusion that as far as wargame campaigns are concerned, this is the 'go to' book ... and will probably remain so for many years to come! As even a brief glance at the contents shows, it pretty well covers everything that a wargamer needs to know about running a wargame campaign, from the small solo effort to the massive club one. There are numerous examples and suggestions for structures and rules, as well as some of Henry's wonderful maps ... which he explains how he created.
I thoroughly recommend this book to my regular blog readers and think that it deserves a place of the bookshelves of anyone and everyone who thinks of themselves as a hobby wargamer.
My only regret is that Henry was unable to include the Snakes & Ladders Campaign System in his book, but I suspect that it emerged at a stage in the book's production where including it would have required a considerable amount of re-writing and re-editing. (Unless one is a self-publisher, an author has to work with a publisher, and to conform to their deadlines. The latter included getting the text, illustrations etc., ready at a specific time so that it can fit into the publishers printing, publication, and distribution schedules. These are often measured in months or even years rather than days or weeks. Late changes are therefore something that can only be done with great difficulty and cost.)
WARGAMING CAMPAIGNS was written by Henry Hyde and published in 2022 by Pen & Sword Military (ISBN 978 1 4738 5591 5).
Thanks for the review Bob. I am pondering buying this, but already have Featherstone's and Tony Bath's books on campaigns, so am not sure if this will bring anything new to the table.
ReplyDeleteSteve J.,
DeleteI also have the two earlier books, and I think that Henry’s book does include new stuff. However, if you already have Donald Featherstone’s and Tony Bath’s books, you already have a solid base for your wargame campaigning.
All the best,
Bob
Thanks for the feedback Bob. For the time being I'll stick with these books and the excellent Warplan 5/5 maps that I use for most, if not all, of my campaigns. Also I dug out your books from my 'library' which have useful info in them too:).
DeleteSteve J.,
DeleteIt sounds as if you have all the bases covered … and thanks for your kind words about my books.
All the best,
Bob
Looks good Bob - on my Wish List!
ReplyDeleteMaudlin Jack Tar,
DeleteI hope that your ‘wish’ is fulfilled soon!
All the best,
Bob
A surprising omission from the list of contents is the word 'logistics'. Does the book cover the supply and manpower aspects of wargame campaigns in any depth?
ReplyDeleteJon,
DeleteLogistics is covered, but only for two pages of the book, so not in the depth that you might want.
All the best,
Bob
Thanks Bob. Sounds like the Schlieffen approach to operations!
DeleteJon,
DeleteWith a touch of Younger Moltke thrown in as well!
All the best,
Bob
I bought a copy on Amazon (but from another seller) for considerably less than Pen &Sword’s discounted price.
ReplyDeleteAll things being equal it should be arriving tomorrow.
Fingers crossed. Cheers,
Geoff
Elliesdad (Geoff),
DeleteYou did well to get it at a lower price.
I had originally ordered mine from Amazon, but when it was published Amazon was still telling me that I would not get my copy until November! I wasnt prepared to wait that long, so cancelled my order and bought it from Pen & Sword instead.
I hope that you enjoy this book. I certainly have, and have lots of ideas whirring around in my head for all sorts of campaigns.
All the best,
Bob
Hi Bob
ReplyDeleteIt looks really interesting, and a welcome addition. I also have the Featherstone and Tony Bath's books, and found them very useful in my early wargaming period. There were two more, which I found even more useful. One was by Paddy Griffiths, it featured the ACW, but could be used for any period. The fourth I can't remember the name, but it has chapters on different aspects of campaigning. The one I found most useful was the chapter on how far armies could move in one day.
I would love to get this latest offer, but dare not. I would be crushed if I found his suggestions were better than my own 1813 campaign. What is that expression - "ignorance is bliss"
regards
Paul
Thistlebarrow,
DeleteWas the Paddy Griffith book BATTLE IN THE AMERICAN CIVIL WAR? It had a companion book entitled BATTLE IN AFRICA, which was written by Howard Whitehouse. They both featured all sorts of tidbits of information that wargamers find really useful.
I can quite understand why buying this book might be a bit counter-productive for you. After all, you’ve been successfully running a campaign for years. In fact, I suspect that the way that you run your campaigns could have been featured in this book.
All the best,
Bob
Paul, with your vast body of first hand experience running campaigns, perhaps YOU should be writing a Wargames campaign book?
DeleteJonathan Freitag,
DeleteI totally agree. I think that Paul's rules and campaigns need a much wider audience.
All the best,
Bob
Hi Jonathan and Bob. Kind of you to suggest , but I have always considered my wargaming style too personal and niche. I long ago gave up trying to make commercial rules fit my style of wargaming. But I am well aware that in doing so I have withdrawn from the general trend. I write the blogs for my own enjoyment and as a record of my wargaming. And I would also like to think that they might encourage others to attempt something similar. But I would never try to claim that my way is in any way better than any other. It has been my experience that many wargamers can be cruel and vindictive to anyone who does not agree with their own prejudices. I can only admire wargamers like Bob or Henry who are brave enough to put their views in book form, particularly these days when it is so much easier to express your ideas in the much safer form of blogging. And it is great to see the massive support Bob receives here on his blog. Long may it continue.
DeleteThistlebarrow,
DeleteI actually think that your rules and your campaigns have a great deal to offer other wargamers. Although there are quite a few who are only interested in the latest, glossy rule books full of colour photos of beautifully painted figures and sculpted terrain (what I have heard called unattainable ‘wargamer porn’!) there are a significant number who are looking to do something that isn’t ‘mainstream’. Your approach is very individual and tailored to your particular requirements … but it serves as an excellent example of what someone can develop over many years of experimentation and playtesting.
If you ever change your mind and want to publish your rules etc., I’d be very willing to give you as much help as I can.
All the best,
Bob
Hi Bob
DeleteThanks for your kind offer. Although my campaign has been going for 13 years (longer than the Peninsular war!) I still consider it a "work in progress". Part of the enjoyment is in being able to amend it to fit new concepts or just game experience. So I don't believe it will ever be ready to be published as a completed commercial project. But most important the very fact that I have designed it to meet my personal prejudices would make it very difficult to defend the same prejudices as a commercial set of rules. Fortunately being able to post regularly as a blogger means that I can have the best of both worlds. I can tailor the rules to my needs without having to defend any of the concepts.
Hower I do envy you having your own wide range of books sitting proudly on your bookshelf. And in terms of number of books published you must rate well against any other writer of wargames books - except perhaps Don Featherstone? In fact the wide range you cover reminds me very much of Don's own efforts.
That is quite an achievement Bob, and I think you should allow yourself a warm glow of satisfaction.
regards
Paul
Thistlebarrow (Paul),
DeleteIf you ever change your mind, just let me know. I know that I’m not alone in thinking that you should publish your rules, but I respect your decision not to … yet! (I live in hope of persuading you otherwise one day!)
I began writing my books because someone suggested that I ought to properly publish the ideas I was writing about on my blog … and the momentum just carried me forward once I had started. It gives me great satisfaction that people have enjoyed what I have written and published … and I still have more books planned!
All the best,
Bob
Thanks for the review! This in does look like a good book to take a squint at.
ReplyDeleteDave Kimmel,
DeleteGlad to have been of assistance.
All the best,
Bob
Very good review, however, at US$65, and the confluence of many current economic issues, I think I will stick with what I have.
ReplyDeleteChris,
DeleteAt that price, if I was you, I’d wait until it is available in electronic format.
All the best,
Bob
Bob,
ReplyDeleteI had the privilege of reading the text in order to help with proofreading and compiling the index. I agree that it was a pity the Snakes & Ladders campaign system was not featured, for the reasons you suggest, which are of course an inherent problem for a book of this type - it can only describe the situation pertaining at the time of writing and cannot be kept up to date with subsequent developments.
Henry is at his best and most entertaining, IMHO, when writing about his ImagiNations of Prunkland et al, and creating rules and campaign systems for such 18th century games.
Personally, I find ideas such as S&L which can be recreated simply without having to become an expert in graphic design and/or computer software far more interesting, so much of the sections on map-making and digital campaigns were of little interest to me.
Blogs such as yours, Grid-based wargaming - but not always, and several others, together with Lone Warrior articles, are where I tend to find most inspiration these days, along with revisiting the books by Featherstone, Wesencraft and Bath.
I tend to agree with Steve J, thistlebarrow and Chris that those books are sufficient, especially if one has to economise on wargame spending. It's a beautiful book, but a luxury, not an essential one for us older wargamers.
Arthur1815 (Arthur),
DeleteAre you becoming the wargame author’s ‘go to’ proofreader? You certainly are as far as I am concerned! In my opinion you are sans pareil!
I agree that Henry’s writing really comes alive when he is dealing with his imagi-nation campaigns. That’s it to say that the rest of the book isn’t well written, it’s just that his enthusiasm shines through in those sections.
The joy of the Snakes & Ladders and Ladder campaign structures is their simplicity, and the fact that you don’t need an intricate map to use them. I like drawing maps … but for my Belle Époque project I plan to use simple maps made up from squares in the style used by Thistlebarrow for his Napoleonic Wargaming campaigns.
I must admit to being a bit of a sucker when it comes to buying wargame books. I can rationalise it that as an author I know how much sales are important and I am helping to support other authors … but the truth is that I treat wargame books in the same way some wargamers treat new ranges of wargame figures. In other words, I see something new and just have to buy it!
All the best,
Bob
Bob,
DeleteI did help with proofreading and draw up the index for Henry's previous Wargaming Compendium and have also proofread for John Curry when the book's subject matter was within my eras of knowledge. You know I will always be ready to proofread any book you publish and if you did ever persuade Thistlebarrow to publish his campaign rules &c - which I agree would be of great interest to many Horse & Musket era wargamers - I would be very happy to help with that, too.
Now Henry has had his two magna opera published, I hope he will tackle less ambitious projects and that we will see more of his articles in wargames magazines again.
Best wishes, Arthur
Arthur1815 (Arthur),
DeleteBeing able to rely on a proofreader who understands about wargaming is something that I treasure. There are plenty of proofreaders out there, but I don’t know of one who is also a wargamer.
I hope that one day Henry will produce a book about his imagi-nation armies and their various wars. I’m sure that it would sell well.
All the best,
Bob
One to add to the shopping list I think.
ReplyDeleteCheers,
Pete.
Pete.,
DeleteI don’t think that you’ll be disappointed.
All the best,
Bob