The first step that I usually take when constructing a 'cartoon' version of a ship design is to take a side view (and if it is available, a plan view as well) of the original design and change the ratio between the length and height by a ratio of 1:2, thus:
I find that this exaggerates the main features of the original design and allows me to get some idea what the end result will look like. This gave me that starting point for the design of my two Burgundian ironclad battleships.
At this point I remembered that Fred Jane had included illustrations of the Amiral Baudin and Formidable in the very first issue of his All The Worlds Fighting Ships. I dug out my reproduction copy and found the images and description of the two ships to be a very useful sources of information.
Amiral Baudin.
Formidable.
I finished building my 'cartoon' versions of the two ships yesterday, and although they are by no means '100% accurate models of the original ships', I think that they do have a passing resemblance.
(I totally accept that I am biased in this view, but they are wargame models designed to be used, and not to be on display in a cabinet.)
I did try fitting shorter funnels, but for some reason they did not look right. The original ships had pronounced tumblehome sides, and I have tried to suggest this by adding 'bulges' to the waterline of the models.
The next step will be to give the two models a couple of coats of PVA to seal the wood. Once that is dry, I will apply a couple of coats of undercoat/primer before painting them in Burgundian livery ... which is likely to be similar to that used by the French Navy at the turn of the century, namely yellow ochre upperworks and a black hull.
Very nice little models....practical representations of the real thing , just like my soldiers...what's not to like. Regards.
ReplyDeleteTony Adams,
DeleteThank you for your kind comment. My ‘cartoon’ models are supposed to be representative rather than precisely accurate models, and although some wargamers hate them, the majority don’t.
All the best,
Bob
Hello there Bob,
ReplyDeleteSpot on in my opinion! I have to say that. Am a bit of a ‘cartoon style’ fanboy and so your models have given me much inspiration over the years. I am looking forward to seeing these painted and in action and it has reminded me that I need to the extend the range of the 3 x 3 Ironclad rules to the end of the century!
Lovely job old chap!
All the best,
DC
David Crook,
DeleteCheers! I think that the ‘cartoon’ style I use is not unlike the easy-to-identify 1:3000th models used in Fred Jane’s games … and where Fred leads, I am more than willing to follow!
I look forward to seeing your next batch of ironclad models.
All the best,
Bob
BOB,
ReplyDeleteA fine bit of modelling for sure- they look great! Well done. Certainly glad you survived the hospital Cheese Sandwich episode...I've no complaints about my stay in Liverpool Hospital in 2020- except "Don't order the Omlette - it is like foam rubber!" he-he! Cheers. KEV.
Kev Robertson (Kev),
DeleteThank you for your praise. It is greatly appreciated.
I had cheese on toast today for lunch … and it was both delicious and easy to eat. I’m not surprised that your omelette was like foam rubber. It’s one of those dishes that you have to eat freshly cooked, not cooked elsewhere and then kept warm before serving.
All the best,
Bob
I really like what you've done with these ships. In the Japanese art style of Manga/Anime these would be termed "super-deformed" or SD for short. I've seen tanks drawn in this style and they're quite endearing. It's fantastic to see your ships crafted in this way!
ReplyDeleteDonjondo,
DeleteI’ve seen some of the Chiba model warships manufactured in Japan, and have wondered if anyone has used them for wargaming. Perhaps they might, now that the 3 x 3 naval game is under development.
All the best,
Bob
Neat technique for designing your ships. I will have to play around with changing the ratios of ships and see what I get.
ReplyDeleteI assume you are out of the hospital and are back home.
--Chris
Chris,
DeleteIf you trawl though my blog, you’ll find other examples I have worked on. I hope that you enjoy playing around with the technique I’ve been using,
I’ve been out of hospital since Tuesday evening, and my life is sort of returning to normal.
All the best,
Bob
I like your ships, looks like they are fun to make!
ReplyDeleteMark Cordone,
DeleteCheers! I find the process of constructing models like these helps to improve my ability to concentrate.
All the best,
Bob
Oh, wow, Bob! I really like these fellows! Apart from some sketches I have kicking around somewhere I've made no progress AT ALL on my Ruberian and Azurian navies...
ReplyDeleteArchduke Piccolo,
DeleteWith so many other projects on the go, I’m not surprised that you have yet to start work on enlarging your Ruberian and Azurian navies. It will come in the fullness of time.
All the best,
Bob
Bob,
ReplyDeleteAs one who has no great affection for ironclad and modern warships, I find your 'cartoon' models very appealing - more so than the real ships on which they are based! I'm sure they will look splendid when painted.
They would also be excellent for an outdoor lawn game and perfect for children as they are robust with no fragile details.
If my children were not adults already, I'd be very tempted to make some for sea battles on our artificial grass in the back garden.
Best wishes, Arthur
Arthur1815 (Arthur),
DeletePraise indeed! If I had a flat lawn - and not one with a one-in-ten slope - I’d build slightly bigger versions of my models so that I could indulge in naval lawn games.
All the best,
Bob
Wow. They're beautiful! Makes me want to try my hand at it.
ReplyDeleteAny chance of a construction guide?
Jennifer,
DeleteCheers! I used a combination of the techniques outlined on my ‘How to …’ pages to build these models.
All the best,
Bob
Your xartoon designs make me realize what I could get away with if I used my boy's 3d printer. They got one as a gift for Christmas and I've been using it to print figures and tanks.
ReplyDeleteAll I need to do now is learn the 3d design software...
I suppose I could make wooden ones faster? LOL.
Mr. Pavone,
DeleteI have been thinking about buying a 3D printer so that I can make models like this … although it would probably be quicker to make it out of wood.
That said, if I could get the program to make the warship token from MONOPOLY and could alter it to suit my requirements, it might be an ideal replacement for or supplement to my wooden models.
All the best,
Bob
I always get a kick out of your little "cartoon" ships made from wood bits. Nice and shipshape!
ReplyDelete(I like that you make them out of wood bits - 3D printing just wouldn't have the same appeal - but might have a different appeal of its own)
Fitz-Badger,
DeleteCheers! I am very pleased that you like my model Burgundian ironclad battleships.
I must admit that although 3D printing has its appeal, I am not sure that it would be worth using to produce one-off designs like my ships. Using wood might take longer, but not by much, and I can play around with the elements before I actually put them together.
All the best,
Bob
You capture the very essence of the ship in your model, most charming Bob.
ReplyDeleteTradgardmastare,
DeleteThanks for your kind comment.
I am currently sketching a design for the Schwarzenberg Navy’s battleships based on rage German ironclads that were built for the Imperial Chinese Navy.
All the best,
Bob
Bob, I really like your little steam punk ships. Please post your builds. I really enjoy coping them. They are fun to build. Would you post your build of the little HMS Empress? I have your Gridded Naval Wargaming book, really cool book. But the Hms Empress is not in there.
ReplyDeleteJohnboy66,
DeleteI’m glad that you like my models.
I use very simple methods, and these can be seen in operation in the relevant ‘How to …’ page on this blog (https://docs.google.com/file/d/0B2axFER4-xZxZzF1WmRtMEdTaEd2TWlSekVTOXYyQQ/edit?resourcekey=0-V7XErX0mBFSiqEu3r3cWSw) HMS Empress was built using the techniques used to build my pre-dreadnought battleship.
All the best,
Bob